Bark and Get Your Message Out


Blogging Corner

Blog by Hans-Peter Plag

Migration: The Unrecognized Existential Challenge for Our Civilization


Migration - the Past

Since the last more than 70,000 years after the eruption of the super volcano Toba, humans, or should I say, sapiens? have migrated. In fact, sapiens evolved into the most invasive of the large mammals, the only one found everywhere on the Earth's surface. Sapiens also became the best in killing of all competing mammals. And we, sapiens, have little that keeps us from killing of other varieties of sapiens. We identify the "others" by language, religion, culture, skin color, or whatever else we come up with.

Migration of large groups was at the basis of sapiens' success as an invasive species. Sapiens migrated because their local population grew beyond the local limits and carrying capacity or because climate conditions changed and made sustaining life impossible. The last ice age, for example, forced humans to live at lower latitudes. When the ice melted, humans migrated into the opening land areas quickly.

Another example: The great famine in Ireland from 1845 to 1852 caused about a million deaths and another million to migrate. Many migrated to North America and put more pressure on the indigenous population. They also helped to build the growing society together with other migrants, or should I say, invaders? Many times, migration in the past led to genocide of the receiving population. Sapiens was seldom hesitant with claiming the new land by creating a "clean plate" to start from.

Particularly a light-skinned variety of sapiens spreading from Europe was very thorough over the last 2,000 years with making sure the plate was clean where ever they reached. They considered, and many of them do even today, all other varieties of sapiens as either a threat or of less value or both. And they had no problems exploiting them or killing them. They called it, and some still do call it, Manifest Destiny.

Migration - the Present

Today, a far too large population is faced with the challenge of increasingly less liveable space being available for sapiens. Self-caused climate change, pollution, and environmental degradation will accelerate the loss of liveable space. Involuntary migration is increasing and challenging the populations in liveable spaces having abundant resources.

Some say that we, who live in those safe and wealthy areas, should help "them" to stay where they are. This is just another way to say, "we don't want them where we are!" Already now we have more then 50 million people migrating not because it is fun to walk 1,000 km and more through dangerous landscapes but because they could not survive anymore where they come from. It is a human right to migrate when living in the current place becomes impossible. In fact, it is in our DNA! If we want this not to be one atrocity after the other we better learn to manage the redistribution of population on Earth's surface effectively for the benefit of all.

Migration - the Injustice

There is injustice in how we look at migration. I am a (voluntary) migrant. I migrated from Germany where I was born to the UK and Norway, then to the US and South Africa, on again to the US, and now to the Caribbean.It was fun to migrate. Nobody tried to tell me to stay in place. My life was good where I was, but I migrated because I hoped for a even better life in those places I migrated too.

But then there are the others who migrate because their life is threatened by other sapiens, by a changed climate, by environmental damage. We want to tell them that they can't come and join our happy migration. We tell them to stay where they are dying. We tell them to stay in places that are unliveable often just because of what we have done to Earth. Where is justice in this?

Migration - the Ethical Challenge

It appears that managing migration ethically in our time is one of the biggest, if not the biggest, challenge we are facing. When Texas and Arizona will be too hot for people to live there, migration into Canada most likely will be peaceful. When the Netherlands will have to be depopulated because of sea-level rise, migration of the Dutch population into other European countries also will be well managed. When 50% of Bangladesh will be under water, I am not so sure the migrants from there will be welcomed in other countries. When most of the land between 30 degrees North and South will be unlivable for sapiens, will the societies in the higher latitudes be willing to help the migrants and welcome them? Or will they turn to more pronatalism to increase the size of their own population?

A big roadblock in reaching justice in migration is inequality in skills and educational background. Getting close to an ethical solution requires a significant reduction of this inequality. The wealthy countries need to invest in global education. Another roadblock is a limited knowledge of “the others” and an understanding of them. Programs and means are needed to increase knowledge of all varieties of sapiens across all varieties. Place4Us could make an important contribution here.

I don't see a way to separate population management, overcoming pronatalism, degradation of the Earth's life-support system, and (involuntary) migration. Saying that we should help "them" in place is just ignoring the scale and nature of the problem. But we need to work on reducing inequalities within and between the varieties of sapiens.

Migration - The Existential Challenge

History shows that migration in many cases led to the killing of the receiving population. Independent of the ethical challenge, do we really think that the relative small (and projected to decrease) population in the wealthy North Atlantic countries will be able to keep out the potentially billions who need to migrated in order to survive? Are we in these wealthy countries willing to support the fascists who would use the full range of weaponry to keep them out so that we could continue our wealthy lives and our voluntary and happy migration in search of a better life?

In the 1980ties, even the UN underestimated the scale the problem of involuntary migration would have in the 2020ties. I think we all underestimated now the scale the problem will have in the 2030ties and 2040ties. It is, in fact, hard to imagine. Programs suggest to tackle the problem include programs for education, family planning, and healthcare. These programs are not even drops of water in the ocean needed to tackle the challenge of population management under a human and planetary existential emergency. I hope that we will eventually understand than an ethical solution is the only way to survival of humanity. But my hope is shrinking ...


Published on Mar 03, 2025, 09:54:01 on blogs at RP, P4US, Overpopulation. Last updated on Mar 02, 2025, 19:16:38.

To submit your comment, please login first.


Blogs of Hans-Peter Plag

Safeguarding the Planetary Life-Support Systems Requires Maintaining the Purpose of These Systems

The purpose of a system is what it does (POSIWID). Since Stafford Beer formulated this foundational statement, a lot of effort has been on designing societal systems that do what their intended purpose is. To a far lesser extent, the statement has been used to determine the purpose of the physiol ...

Published on 2023/10/11/11/24/ by Hans-Peter Plag

Changing What We Do is Changing the Story

György Buzsáki (2022) states that "Perception is what we do." Christof Koch (2019) describes consciousness as "the feeling of life itself." The feeling of life is the result of our perception of the inside and outside worlds combined. Then, what we do is what we feel and what we a ...

Published on 2022/10/12/09/32/00 by Hans-Peter Plag

On the Importance of Choices

Barry said a few days ago that the web pages of Place4Us offer too many choices. He claimed that people get confused and don't want to have so many choices.

I agree that young people today live in a world where choices are made for them by algorithms. During the time they spend with their sma ...

Published on by Hans-Peter Plag

AI Does not have the “Feeling of Life Itself” - it is Depleting our Life Experience

In many publication considering the challenges or dangers of AI, the fact that AI can do many things better than humans is the basis for a reasoning that AI might take jobs away from people and increase productivity. This is a fundamentally flawed view on the impact of AI. It is flawed because it ...

Published on 2023/04/11/00/10/00 by Hans-Peter Plag

The Meaning of Life

It's not about what we can do but about what we feel when we do it.

It's not about the poem we write but about what the poem we write does to us.

While Generative Artificial Intelligence tools might write poems that seem to be better than our poems, writing the poem will not create an exp ...

Published on 2023/08/27/10/24/00 by Hans-Peter Plag

Migration: The Unrecognized Existential Challenge for Our Civilization

Migration - the Past


Since the last more than 70,000 years after the eruption of the super volcano Toba, humans, or should I say, sapiens? have migrated. In fact, sapiens evolved into the most invasive of the large mammals, the only one found everywhere on the Earth's surface. Sapiens ...

Published on 2025/03/02/19/16/42 by Hans-Peter Plag

Jumping Frogs and Boiling People

A Flawed Myth



There is a myth based on experiments in the 1840ties that a frog would react to rapid changes but not to a slowly warming water. The myth contented that a frog thrown in boiling water would jump out, but a frog sitting in water that slowly is heated up would not jump out ...

Published on 2025/03/08/20/24/02 by Hans-Peter Plag



Our Bloggers on Place4Us

Barry Clemson
Hans-Peter Plag
Jamie Heffernan

Search in all VCCs: No Yes